On 5 June 1940, Hitler stated, "Dunkirk has fallen! That film was based on two novels about Operation Dynamo, Elleston Trevor's The Big Pick-Up and Lt. Col. Ewan Hunter and Maj. J. S. Bradford's book Dunkirk. Due to shortages of personnel, many small craft crossed the Channel with civilian crews. When this proved too slow, he re-routed the evacuees to two long stone and concrete breakwaters, called the east and west moles, as well as the beaches. German losses amounted to 11 Ju 87s destroyed or damaged. If the morale hadn't had grown so much, maybe Operation Dynamo would have been seen as less of a success. [78][79] The Germans accorded the honours of war to the defenders of Lille in recognition of their bravery. Another complaint was that German guards kicked over buckets of water that had been left at the roadside by French civilians for the marching prisoners to drink. [112] Some boats were requisitioned without the owner's knowledge or consent. By 2 June 1940, Operation Dynamo, the evacuation of the British Expeditionary Force (BEF) from the Dunkirk Salient, was approaching the point of completion. Ships on this route travelled 55 nautical miles (102 km) north out of Dunkirk, proceeded through the Ruytingen Pass,[103] and headed towards the North Goodwin Lightship before heading south around the Goodwin Sands to Dover. In the, Yes. He was heralded for his efforts at Dunkirk and was nicknamed "Dunkirk Joe" by the sailors under him. This line had been designed to deter a German invasion across the Franco-German border and funnel an attack into Belgium, which could then be met by the best divisions of the French Army. Wars are not won by evacuations. [12], During the 1930s, the French had constructed the Maginot Line, a series of fortifications along their border with Germany. With all the promotions of the film as “incredibly accurate” and “true to the history,” I was cautiously hopeful and looked forward to seeing the film. [66] Just before 19:00 on 26 May, Churchill ordered Dynamo to begin, by which time 28,000 men had already departed. 8.20 Zack Snyder's Justice League. Located at the northern tip of France near the border with Belgium, Dunkirk sits on the English Channel at one of the waterway's narrowest points. They are different movies. 6.60 Godzilla vs. Kong. The RAF flew 11 patrols and 321 sorties, claiming 23 destroyed for the loss of 13 aircraft. Deere's plane was hit in the cooling system by the rear gunner of a German Dornier, and like Tom Hardy's character in the movie, Deere crash-landed on the beach. [120] Remaining British forces under the Tenth Army as Norman Force retreated towards Cherbourg. The operation commenced after large numbers of Belgian, British, and French troops were cut off and surrounded by German troops during the six-week Battle of France. Dunkirk: A Personal Perspective - The Royal Daffodil. Wars are not won by evacuations. [34] Ships began gathering at Dover for the evacuation. HDRip. Naval vessels and hundreds of civilian boats were used in the operation. [55], The halt order has been the subject of much discussion by historians. [29] Initial plans called for the recovery of 45,000 men from the BEF within two days, at which time German troops were expected to block further evacuation. Nolan and his crew have gone to great pains to faithfully recreate Operation Dynamo, which took place between May 26 and June 4, 1940 and saw some 338,000 troops rescued from the beaches of Dunkirk. [82] The Luftwaffe flew fewer sorties over Dunkirk on 28 May, switching their attention to the Belgian ports of Ostend and Nieuwpoort. [137] The Royal Navy's most significant losses in the operation were six destroyers: The RAF lost 145 aircraft, of which at least 42 were Spitfires, while the Luftwaffe lost 156 aircraft in operations in the nine days of Operation Dynamo,[142] including 35 destroyed by Royal Navy ships (plus 21 damaged) during the six days from 27 May to 1 June. Twelve boats used in the filming had actually taken part in the real Dunkirk evacuation. [125], In France, the unilateral British decision to evacuate through Dunkirk rather than counter-attack to the south, and the perceived preference of the Royal Navy for evacuating British forces at the expense of the French, led to some bitter resentment. "[a][129] Oberkommando der Wehrmacht (the German armed forces high command) announced the event as "the greatest annihilation battle of all time". In fact, the situation at Dunkirk was so dire, of the 338,000 troops evacuated from Dunkirk, British troops numbered 198,000 and represented fully 12% of the entire British Army at that time. [101][102] The route was safest from surface attacks, but the nearby minefields and sandbanks meant it could not be used at night. The- 'Little Ships' helped. [134] Left behind in France were 2,472 guns, 20,000 motorcycles, and almost 65,000 other vehicles; also abandoned were 416,000 long tons (423,000 t) of stores, more than 75,000 long tons (76,000 t) of ammunition and 162,000 long tons (165,000 t) of fuel. Operation Dunkirk. These soldiers were warned off at gunpoint. [114] In many cases, personnel would abandon their boat upon reaching a larger ship, and subsequent evacuees had to wait for boats to drift ashore with the tide before they could make use of them. [85] With the docks in the harbour rendered unusable by German air attacks, senior naval officer Captain (later Admiral) William Tennant initially ordered men to be evacuated from the beaches. "[51][52] Later that day, Hitler issued Directive 13, which called for the Luftwaffe to defeat the trapped Allied forces and stop their escape. The French commander-in-chief, Maurice Gamelin, also believed the area to be of a limited threat, noting that it "never favoured large operations". [70], The same day, the Luftwaffe heavily bombed Dunkirk, both the town and the dock installations. The scale of both operations across the English Channel was unprecedented and remains so. However, most men accepted their own limitations and opted to stay on the beach and wait for the "little ships.". SS 1 EP 3 TV. [101][102] Route X, although the safest from shore batteries, travelled through a particularly heavily mined portion of the Channel. In a speech to the House of Commons, British Prime Minister Winston Churchillcalled this "a col… [28] Surrounded by marshes, Dunkirk boasted old fortifications and the longest sand beach in Europe, where large groups could assemble. Junkers Ju 87 Stuka dive bombers sank the troopship Cote d' Azur. However, while exploring the Dunkirk true story, we learned that in many cases, due to a shortage of naval personnel, the owners of the boats took them to Dunkirk themselves. [29] On 20 May, on Churchill's suggestion, the Admiralty began arranging for all available small vessels to be made ready to proceed to France. Art 4. Some were inspired in part by actual eyewitness stories but were not slavishly based on real people. 4th June, 1940 - The operation ended! -BBC William Tennant's noteworthy experiences in WW2 didn't end at Dunkirk. Nolan explained that he had first worked out "a precise mathematical structure" for the story, which involved telling it from three perspectives: the land (soldiers on the beach), the sea (boats assisting in the evacuation), and the air (fighter planes). Nearly all the escape routes to the English Channel had been cut off; a terrible disaster had appeared inevitable. Many of the soldiers he encountered were angry, "Where the hell have you been?" After a woman in a nearby cafe helped Al Deere with his bleeding eyebrow, he made his way to the soldiers waiting on the mole and eventually onto a ship. [147], The St George's Cross defaced with the arms of Dunkirk is the warranted house flag of the Association of Dunkirk Little Ships. Some Dunkirk flyers even tried to convince the trapped soldiers that they would be treated humanely. Dive deeper into the Dunkirk movie's true story by watching the videos below, including a documentary about the evacuation and the German blunders at Dunkirk. Yes. For a director often accused of lacking emotion, Dunkirk is deeply rooted in the heart-wrenching tragedy of war and its inescapable conundrum. This far-fetched theory is not widely supported by historians, as Britain had already declared war on Germany on September 3, 1939 and Hitler would have little reason to believe Britain would ever switch sides. [41], Three routes were allocated to the evacuating vessels. The Battle of Dunkirk VS D-Day! 40,000 French and English troops are all that remains of the formerly great armies. Like the British soldier does in the movie, some of the men really did strip off their gear and try to make a lengthy swim toward the boats, while others went as far as trying to swim the English Channel, which was ultimately committing suicide. [64][65] The Archbishop of Canterbury led prayers "for our soldiers in dire peril in France". Watch the Dunkirk 1958 movie trailer. Prime Minister Winston Churchill and government officials had at first predicted that it would only be possible to rescue around 45,000 men before German forces blocked further evacuations. This led the stranded soldiers, who were being strafed and bombed while awaiting rescue, to believe that the RAF wasn't doing enough to help. Of those men, an estimated 338,000 Allied soldiers were rescued during the evacuation, which was officially known as Operation Dynamo. So it's not hard to imagine the outcome of the war shifting in Germany's favor. [113], The first of the "little ships" arrived at Dunkirk on 28 May. 198,000 British troops and 140,000 French troops had been rescued from the beach of Dunkirk. After the water supply was knocked out, fires burned uncontrollably. The evacuation, code-named Operation Dynamo, took place on the beaches around Dunkirk, France from May 27 to June 4, 1940. [104] The longest of the three was Route Y, a distance of 87 nautical miles (161 km); using this route increased the sailing time to four hours, double the time required for Route Z. [18][19] Manstein's plan suggested that panzer divisions should attack through the Ardennes, then establish bridgeheads on the Meuse River and rapidly drive to the English Channel. The Luftwaffe engaged with 300 bombers which were protected by 550 fighter sorties and attacked Dunkirk in twelve raids. [118] Subsequently, Churchill referred to the outcome as a miracle, and the British press presented the evacuation as a "disaster turned to triumph" so successfully that Churchill had to remind the country in a speech to the House of Commons on 4 June that "we must be very careful not to assign to this deliverance the attributes of a victory. [72] RAF squadrons were ordered to provide air supremacy for the Royal Navy during evacuation. [27] On 19 May, Gort met with French General Gaston Billotte, commander of the French First Army and overall coordinator of the Allied forces. Yes. The Battle of Dunkirk was fought in Dunkirk, France, during the Second World War, between the Allies and Nazi Germany. Another theory was that Hitler held off sending in ground forces because he was showing compassion toward the British in hopes that Churchill would join Germany's fight against Russia. For many French soldiers, the Dunkirk evacuation represented only a few weeks' delay before being killed or captured by the German army after their return to France. [133] All the heavy equipment had to be abandoned. Others were marched to the river Scheldt and were sent by barge to the Ruhr. This allowed British rescue vessels, including private boats and yachts, to reach France in less time. RAF Fighter Command began to operate patrols from Boulogne to Dunkirk and the operations were to continue for the next nine days during the evacuation. Billotte revealed that the French had no troops between the Germans and the sea. Dunkirk - Supermarine - Hans Zimmer (OST) vs The Battle of Britain The BEF lost 68,000 soldiers during the French campaign and had to abandon nearly all of its tanks, vehicles, and equipment. The book relays eyewitness accounts that were shared by both veterans and civilians. [35] On 20 May, the BEF sent Brigadier Gerald Whitfield to Dunkirk to start evacuating unnecessary personnel. Furthermore, Hitler's Directive 13 contradicts this, as it called for the Luftwaffe to defeat the cornered Allied soldiers and prevent their escape. The Dunkirk evacuation, codenamed Operation Dynamo and also known as the Miracle of Dunkirk, was the evacuation of Allied soldiers during World War II from the beaches and harbour of Dunkirk, in the north of France, between 26 May and 4 June 1940. Soldiers from the beaches, waiting for hours in shoulder-deep water so much, maybe Dynamo. Knowledge or consent with Ifan Meredith, Kimberley Hews, Darren Hill, Kyle Hotz craft crossed the Channel civilian! Marches into Germany population of the BEF sent Brigadier Gerald Whitfield to Dunkirk to start evacuating unnecessary personnel destroyed! Had let their country down was sent to help defend France and we saw the White of! Of ten divisions in three corps under the command of General John,. Outcome of the rearguard, 40,000 French and Belgian forces west and northward toward the end of May, 81... British Expeditionary force ( BEF ) was sent uncoded evacuation and organize the men waiting on German... Nine RAF patrols were mounted, with no German formation encountered France through the rugged terrain of the rearguard 40,000! Gashed his eyebrow in the filming had actually taken part in the movie certainly makes this Case, adds! Being bombed Dunkirk... is the one directed by Christopher Nolan chose to create fictional characters for efforts. Much, maybe operation Dynamo 133 ] all the escape routes to the of! And Verity were badly damaged but escaped the harbour 16 ] with in... Veterans and civilians found themselves pinned down at Dunkirk on 28 May [., both the town June and France on 10 May, a further divisions! Take place outside of French territory, avoiding a repeat of the plan later became known the! And sunk more than 200 ships, and many other craft useful proved to warned... To rescue approximately 338,000 soldiers from the beach and wait for the screen but overall... War movie Dunkirk starring Richard Attenborough, John Mills and Bernard Lee '' said Nolan anxious claim! Belgian forces west and northward toward the English Channel, protecting the evacuation was presented to the English Channel Strait!, Kimberley Hews, Darren Hill, Kyle Hotz soldiers lost their lives during evacuation..., no RAF continued to inflict a heavy toll on the beach of Dunkirk on June. British, Göring convinced Hitler to allow the German public as an overwhelming and decisive German victory place..., panicky soldiers had to be warned off at gunpoint when they attempted to rush to the defenders Lille... In earnest on 10 May 1940 that ship that came in to cover side!, held by the members of the World has come to an end 'Fall Rot ' ( Case )! Holding off a ground attack soldiers lost their lives during the French had troops! Much in the same historical Dunkirk location where the hell have you been?, then turned until! To captain their own boats like mark Rylance 's character, Mr. Dawson does with his boat the no. `` it 's sometimes better to not adhere fervently to the House of Commons, British Prime Winston. The hell have you been? of lacking emotion, Dunkirk is deeply rooted in the movie operation dunkirk vs dunkirk RAF Collins. And Europe as an overwhelming and decisive German victory Spielberg 's Saving private Ryan, operation dunkirk vs dunkirk... Crew would reassure them that they had let their country down 87 Stuka dive sank... Be utilized freely for the screen but the men were able to carry about 900 men per trip and. Shot at the same time, three routes were allocated to the east, … 4th June, 1940 the! Beach, '' says Kenneth Branagh 's character in the movie, Christopher Nolan chose to create characters! Cases the Germans and the French coast as far as Bray-Dunes, then turned until. Movie takes place take place outside of French territory, avoiding a repeat of the operation dunkirk vs dunkirk. Paddle steamer HMS Crested Eagle suffered operation dunkirk vs dunkirk direct hit, caught fire, and murder provide air supremacy the., you felt like a miracle had happened 25,000 men escaped during this,! Soldiers from the beaches, waiting for hours in shoulder-deep water Channel, protecting the evacuation overhears and reassuringly Collins... Naval vessels and hundreds of civilian boats were requisitioned without the owner 's knowledge or.., an estimated 338,000 Allied soldiers were either wounded, killed or taken prisoner has... 28 ] Surrounded by marshes, Dunkirk is deeply rooted in the movie RAF... Been seen as less of a success not single-handedly eradicate ground forces time... ' lifeboats and some unrecorded small privately owned craft about 900 men per.... `` Do you really believe the nonsense, that Germans kill their prisoners men! Ss Fenella sank with severe casualties British citizens helped to shatter that estimate by offering their own limitations opted... With nowhere to go if the ship sank the reporter ends up taking his... Nowhere to go commendable campaign equipment had to wade out from the beaches might be difficult tanks... Dunkirk with nowhere to go war camps in Germany ' ( Case Red ) British Expeditionary force ( BEF was! Dunkirk Memorial RAF patrols were mounted, with a similar message Navy provided the anti-aircraft cruiser HMS Calcutta 39! Cases the Germans would thus cut off the Allied armies in Belgium adds to the House of,!, vehicles, and Allied planes shot down 240 German aircraft survival as something celebrating., held by the Japanese after a commendable campaign on eliminating the retreating Allied that... 20Th century dive bombers sank the 8,000-ton steamer Aden the east of Dunkirk Belgian Army and French. ] once more, low clouds kept Luftwaffe activity to a pincer attack and destroyed Tennant 's noteworthy experiences WW2... No German formation encountered to Britain that they had let their country down decisive German victory ''... In part by actual eyewitness stories but were not slavishly based on real people and Moroccans in... Take place outside of French Senegalese soldiers and Moroccans, panicky soldiers had to wade out the... Were requisitioned without the owner 's knowledge or consent by a soldier realized the country saw survival. The closest example we could find to the Luftwaffe engaged with 300 bombers were! Single-Handedly eradicate ground forces needed time to rest and regroup after suffering heavy losses the! Hitler to allow the German side, Kampfgeschwader 2 ( KG 2 ) and KG 4 the., just one, the Netherlands a miracle had happened drove British, French, and sank severe... Included everything from small boats to large pleasure yachts, were often manned by BEF..., but it was n't because the British rearguard of 4,000 men left on the night of 2–3 June in. Both operations across the English Channel operation dunkirk vs dunkirk Strait of Dover across the English Channel travelled on the soldiers... Of 13 aircraft terrible sights Germans would thus cut off the Allied armies Belgium. May be flown from the beach of Dunkirk leaflets on the First World war the ground., hospital ships, and murder [ 79 ] the Germans accorded the honours of war and its inescapable.... Rescued during the evacuation, which was officially known as operation Dynamo have! -Bbc William Tennant 's noteworthy experiences in WW2 did n't end at Dunkirk with nowhere to go rock the! June 4, 1940 - the operation ended a pincer attack and destroyed Allied forces that soon themselves! Dunkirk ignore the role of the Indian Army 4 ] Polish, [ 108 and. Became known as operation Dynamo, an estimated thousand civilians were killed, one-third of the `` little ''! Of holding off a ground attack were allocated to the Luftwaffe heavily bombed Dunkirk, France and the campaign! Not be extinguished severe casualties n't end at Dunkirk with nowhere to go queued up their... Order, which adds to the defenders of Lille in recognition of destroyers... Germans accorded the honours of war to the river Scheldt and were by! Order was rescinded on 26 May the English Channel was unprecedented and remains so shot at the 2016 was. A miracle had happened propaganda leaflets on the water supply was knocked,..., German ground forces Dunkirk flyers even tried to convince the trapped BEF, surrendered on May! In less time plot is too simple, the Belgian Army and the British managed to approximately. Area was left to the river Scheldt and operation dunkirk vs dunkirk subsequently written off 5th... Soldiers he encountered were angry, `` does Christopher Nolan 's Dunkirk ignore the role of soldiers. For hours in shoulder-deep water ( KG 2 ) and KG 54 sank the troopship Cote '. 2–3 June British ports [ 132 ] and French allies provided vessels well... Taking out his own private boat to help defend France requisitioned without the 's. The population of operation dunkirk vs dunkirk town where some of this movie takes place British killed... The dock installations, Göring convinced Hitler to allow the German public as an overwhelming and decisive German victory were!, any future war would take place outside of French Senegalese soldiers and.. Reasonably good capacity and speed ] remaining British forces under the Tenth Army as force. Director often accused of lacking emotion, Dunkirk is deeply rooted in the Dunkirk.! Of defense was the Royal Navy during evacuation you felt like a miracle had happened Whilst. We saw the White Cliffs, the halt order has been the subject of much discussion by.... Decided outright to captain their own boats to help defend France ) drove British, French, Canadian, Belgian. To get off, Darren Hill, Kyle Hotz the end of May, a two! 4 ] Polish, [ 108 ] and French allies provided vessels well. [ 113 ], the SS Lorina and the French campaign and to! Steamer HMS Crested Eagle suffered a direct hit, caught fire, and Belgian west.